Wars and Battles

The Holy Qur’an on War and Peace

An understanding of Islam’s teachings in warfare including the treatment of prisoners.

The teaching of Islam is different from both these teachings. It strikes a mean between the two. Islam does not teach aggression as did M o s e s( a s ). Nor does it, like present-day (and presumably corrupt) Christianity, preach a contradiction. It does not ask us to turn the other cheek and at the same time to sell our clothes to buy a sword. The teaching of Islam fits into the natural instincts of man, and promotes peace in the only possible way. Islam forbids aggression, but it urges us to fight if failure to fight jeopardizes peace and promotes war. If failure to fight means the extirpation of free belief and of the search of truth, it is our duty to fight. This is the teaching on which peace can ultimately be built, and this is the teaching on which the Prophet(sa) based his own policies and his practice. The Pr o p h e t( s a ) s u f f e r e d continuously and consistently at Mecca but did not fight the aggression of which he was an innocent victim. When he escaped to Medina, the enemy was out to extirpate Islam; it was, therefore, necessary to fight the enemy in defence of truth and freedom of belief. We quote below the passages in the Qur’an which bear on the subject of war. (i) In Ch.22: Vs.40-42 we have. Permission to fight is given to those against whom war is made, because they have been wronged – and Allah indeed has power to help them – Those who have been driven out from their homes unjustly only 48 Review of Religions – February 2002 The Qur’an on War and Peace This is an extract taken from the book Introduction to the study of the Holy Qur’an, written by Hadhrat Mirza Bashir-ud-din mahmud Ahmad because they said, ‘Our Lord is Allah’ – And if Allah did not repel some men by means of others, there would surely have been pulled down cloisters and churches and synagogues and mosques, wherein the name of Allah is oft commemorated. And Allah will surely help one who helps Him. Allah is indeed Powerful, Mighty. – T h o s e who, if We establish them in the earth, will observe Prayer and pay the ZakSt and enjoin good and forbid evil. And with Allah rests the final issue of all affairs. The verse purports to say that permission to fight is given to the victims of aggression. God is well able to help the victims-those who have been driven out of their homes because of their beliefs. The permission is wise because, if God were not to repel the cruel with the help of the righteous, there would be no freedom of faith and worship in the world. God must help those who help to establish freedom and worship. It follows that fighting is permitted when a people have suffered long from wanton aggression – when the aggressor has had no cause for aggression and he seeks to interfere with the religion of his victim. The duty of the victim, if and when he attains to power, is to establish religious freedom and to protect all religions and all religious places. His power is to be used not for his own glorification, but for the care of the poor, the progress of the country and the general promotion of peace. This teaching is as unexceptionable as it is clear and precise. It proclaims the fact that early Muslims took to war because they were constrained to do so. Aggressive wars were forbidden by Islam. Muslims are promised political power, but are warned that this power must be used not for self- aggrandizement, but for the amelioration of the poor and the promotion of peace and progress. 49 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 (2) In Ch.2: Vs191-194 we have And fight in the cause of Allah against those who fight against you, but do not transgress. Surely, Allah loves not transgressors. And kill them wherever you meet them and drive them out from where they have driven you out; for persecution is worse than killing. And fight them not in, and near, the Sacred Mosque until they fight you, then fight them: such is the requital for the disbelievers. But if they desist, then surely Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful. And fight them until there is no persecution, and religion is professed for Allah. But if they desist, then remember that no hostility is allowed except against the aggressors. Fighting is to be for the sake of God, not for our own sake or out of anger or aggrandize- ment, and even fighting is to be free from excesses, for excesses are displeasing to God. Fighting is between parties of combatants. Assaults on individuals are forbidden. Aggression against a religion is to be met by active resistance, for such aggression is worse than bloodshed. Muslims are not to fight near the Sacred Mosque, unless an attack is first made by the enemy. Fighting near the Sacred Mosque interferes with the public right of pilgrimage. But if the enemy attacks, Muslims are free to r e p l y, this being the just reward of aggression. But if 50 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 FIGHTING IS TO BE FOR THE SAKE OF GOD, NOT FOR OUR OWN SAKE OR OUT OF ANGER OR AGGRANDIZEMENT, AND EVEN FIGHTING IS TO BE FREE FROM EXCESSES, FOR EXCESSES ARE DISPLEASING TO GOD. FIGHTING IS BETWEEN PARTIES OF COMBATANTS. ASSAULTS ON INDIVIDUALS ARE FORBIDDEN. the enemy desists, Muslims must desist also, and forgive and forget the past. Fighting is to continue so long as religious persecution lasts and religious freedom is not established. Religion is for God. The use of force or pressure in religion is wrong. If the Kafirs desist from it and make religion free, Muslims are to desist from fighting the Kafirs. Arms are to be taken up against those who commit excesses. When excesses cease, fighting must cease also. Categorically, we may say, the verses teach the following rules: (i) War is to be resorted to only for the sake of God and not for the sake of any selfish motives, not for aggrandize- ment or for the advancement of any other interests. (ii) We can go to war only against one who attacks us first. (iii) We can fight only those who fight against us. We can- not fight against those who take no part in warfare. (iv) Even after the enemy has initiated the attack, it is our duty to keep warfare within limits. To extend the war, either territorially or in respect of weapons used, is wrong. (v) We are to fight only a regular army charged by the enemy to fight on his side. We are not to fight others on the enemy side. (vi) In warfare immunity is to be afforded to all religious rites and observances. If the enemy spares the places where religious ceremonies are held, then Muslims also must desist from fighting in such places. (vii) If the enemy uses a place of worship as a base for attack, then Muslims may return the attack. No blame will attach to them if they do so. No fighting is allowed even in the neighbourhood of religious places. To attack 51 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 religious places and to destroy them or to do any kind of harm to them is absolutely for- bidden. A religious place used as a base of operations may invite a counter-attack. The responsibility for any harm done to the place will then rest with the enemy, not with Muslims. (viii) If the enemy realizes the danger and the mistake of using a religious place as a base, and changes the battlefront, then Muslims must conform to the change. The fact that the enemy started the attack from a religious place is not to be used as an excuse for attacking that place. Out of reverence Muslims must change their battle-front as soon as the enemy does so. (ix) Fighting is to continue only so long as interference with religion and religious freedom lasts. When religion becomes free and interference with it is no longer permitted and the enemy declares and begins to act accordingly, then there is to be no war, even if it is the enemy who starts it. (3) In Ch.8: Vs.39-41 we have Say to those who dis- believe, if they desist, that which is past will be forgiven them; and if they return thereto, then verily the example of the former people has already gone before them. And fight them until there is no persecution and relgion is w h o l l y for Allah. But if they desist, then surely Allah is Watchful of what they do. And if they turn their backs, then know that Allah is your Protector. What an excellent Protector and what an excellent Helper. That is to say, wars have been forced upon Muslims. But if the enemy desists, it is the duty of Muslims to desist also and forgive the past. But if the enemy does not desist and attacks Muslims again and again, then he should remember the fate of the 52 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 enemies of earlier Prophets. Muslims are to fight, while religious perse-cution lasts, and so long as religion is not for God and inter-ference in religious matters is not abandoned. When the aggres- sor desists, Muslims are to desist also. They are not to continue the war because the enemy believes in a false religion. The value of beliefs and actions is well known to God and He will reward them as He pleases. Muslims have no right to meddle with another people’s religion even if that religion seems to them to be false. If after an offer of peace the enemy continues to make war, then Muslims may be sure of victory even though their numbers are small. For God will help them and who can help better than God? These verses were revealed in connection with the Battle of Badr. This battle was the first regular fight between Muslims and disbelievers. In it Muslims were the victims of unpro- voked aggression. The enemy had chosen to disturb the peace of Medina and of the territory around. In spite of this, victory went to the Muslims and important leaders of the enemy were killed. To retaliate against such unpro- voked aggression seems natural, just and necessary. Yet Muslims are taught to stop fighting as soon as the enemy ceases it. All that the enemy is required to concede is freedom of belief and worship. (4) In Ch.8: Vs.62-63 we have: And if they incline towards peace, incline thou also towards it, and put thy trust in Allah. Surely, it is He Who is AllHearing, All- Knowing. And if they intend to deceive thee, then surely Allah is sufficient for thee. He it is Who has strengthened thee with His help and with the believers. That is to say, if in the course of a battle, the disbelievers at any time incline towards peace, Muslims are to accept the offer at once and to make 53 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 peace. Muslims are to do so even at the risk of being deceived. They are to put their trust in God. Cheating will not avail against Muslims, who rely on the help of God. Their victories are due not to themselves but to God. In the darkest and most difficult times, God has stood by the Prophet(sa) and his followers. So will He stand by them against cheats. An offer of peace is to be accepted. It is not to be rejected on the plea that it may only be a ruse with which the enemy seeks to gain time for a fresh attack. The stress on peace in the verses is not without signif- icance. It anticipates the peace which the Pr o p h e t( s a ) signed at Hudaibiya. The Pr o p h e t( s a ) is warned that a time will come when the enemy will sue for peace. The offer is not to be turned down on the ground that the enemy was the aggressor and had committed excesses, or that he cannot be trusted. The straight path inculcated by Islam requires a Muslim to accept an offer of peace. Both piety and policy make the acceptance desirable. (5) In Ch.4: V.95 we have: O ye who believe when you go forth in the cause of Allah, make proper investi- gation and say not to anyone who greets you with the greeting of peace, ‘Thou art not a believer.’ You seek the goods of this life, but with Allah are good things in p l e n t y. Such were you before this, but Allah conferred His favour on you; so do make proper investigation. Surely, Allah is well aware of what you do. That is to say, when Muslims go out for war, they are to make sure that the unreason- ableness of war has been explained to the enemy and that he still wants war. Even so, if a proposal of peace is received from an individual or a group, Muslims are not to turn it down on the plea that it is not honest. If Muslims turn down proposals of peace, they 54 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 will not be fighting for God, but for self-aggrandizement and worldly gain. Just as religion comes from God, worldly gain and glory also come from Him. Killing is not to be the aim. One whom we wish to kill today may be guided tomorrow. Could Muslims have become Muslims if they had not been spared? Muslims are to abstain from killing because lives spared may turn out to be lives guided. God is well aware of what men do and to what ends and with what motives they do i t . The verse teaches that even after war has begun, it is the duty of Muslims to satisfy themselves that the enemy is bent upon aggression. It often happens that no aggression is intended but that out of excitement and fear the enemy has started prepa- rations for war. Unless Muslims are satisfied that an aggressive attack has been planned by the enemy, they are not to go to war. If it turns out, or if the enemy claims, that his prepa- rations are for self-defence, Muslims are to accept the claim and desist from war. They are not to argue that the enemy prepa-rations point to nothing but aggression; maybe he intended aggression, but his intention has changed. Are not intentions and motives continually changing? Did not enemies of Islam become friends? (6) On the inviolability of treaties the Qur’an says clearly: Excepting those of the idolaters with whom you have entered into a treaty and who have not subsequently failed you in anything nor aided anyone against you. So fulfil to these the treaty you have made with them till their term. Surely, Allah loves those who are righteous. (Ch.9: v.4) Pagans, who enter into a pact with Muslims, keep the pact and do not help the enemy against Muslims, are to have 55 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 reciprocal treatment from Muslims. Piety requires that Muslims should fulfil their part of a pact in the letter as well as the spirit. (7) Of an enemy at war with Muslims who wishes to study the Message of Islam, the Qur’an orders: And if anyone of the idolaters ask protection of thee, grant him protection, so that he may hear the word of Allah : then convey him to his place of security. That is because they are a people who have no k n o w l e d g e . (Ch.9: v.6) That is to say, if any of those at war with Muslims seek refuge with Muslims in order to study Islam and ponder over its Message, they are to have refuge with Muslims for such time as may be reasonably necessary for such a purpose. (8) Of prisoners of war, the Qur’an teaches: It does not behove a Prophet that he should have captives until he engages in a regular fighting in the land. You desire the goods of the world, while Allah desires for you the Hereafter. And Allah is Mighty, Wise. (Ch.8: v.68) That is to say, it does not become a Prophet to make prisoners of his enemy save as a result of regular war involving much bloodshed. The system of making prisoners of enemy tribes without war and blood-shed practised untiland even after the advent of Islam, is here made unlawful. Prisoners can be taken only from combatants and after a battle. (9) Rules for the release of prisoners are also laid down. Thus we have: Then afterwards either release them as a favour or by taking ransom – until the war lays down its burdens. (Ch.47: v.5) 56 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 The best thing, according to Islam, is to let off prisoners without asking for ransom. As this is not always possible, release by ransom is also provided for. (I0) There is provision for prisoners of war who are unable themselves to pay, and who have none who can or will pay, for their release. Often, relations are able to pay, but do not, because they prefer to let their relations remain prisoners possibly with the intention of misappropriating their property in their absence. This provision is contained in the Qur’an: And such as desire a deed of manumission from among those whom your right hands possess, write it for them, if you know any good in them; and give them out of the wealth of Allah which He has bestowed upon you. (Ch.24: v.34) That is, those who do not deserve to be released without ransom but who have no one to pay ransom for them – if they still ask for their freedom, can obtain it by signing an undertaking that, if allowed to work and earn, they will pay their ransom. They are to be allowed to do so, however, only if their competence to work and earn is reasonably certain. If their competence is proved, they should even have financial help from Muslims in their effort to work and earn. Individual Muslims who can afford to do so should pay or public sub-scription should be raised to put these unfor- tunhates on their feet. The passages from the Qur’an which we have quoted above contain the teaching of Islam on the subject of war and peace. They tell us in what circum-stances, according to Islam, is it right to go to war and what limits have to be observed by Mluslims when they make war. Muslim teaching, however, does not consist only of precepts laid down in the 57 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 Qur’an. It also includes the precepts and example of the Pr o p h e t( s a ). What he did or what he taught in concrete situations is also an essential part of the Islamic teaching. We append here some sayings of the Pr o p h e t( s a ) on the subject of war and peace. • Muslims are forbidden altogether to mutilate the dead. (Muslim) • Muslims are forbidden to resort to cheating. (Muslim) • Children are not to be killed, nor women. (Muslim) • Priests and religious functionaries and religious leaders are not to be interfered with. (Tahavi) • The old and decrepit and women and children are not to be killed. The possibility of peace should always be kept in view. (Abu Dawud) • When Muslims enter enemy t e r r i t o r y, they should not strike terror into the general population. They should permit no ill-treatment of common folk. (Muslim) • A Muslim army should not camp in a place where it causes inconvenience to the general public. When it marches it should take care not to block the road nor cause discomfort to other wayfarers. • No disfigurement of face is to be permitted. (Bukhari and Muslim) • The least possible losses should be inflicted upon the enemy. (Abu Dawud) • When prisoners of war are put under guard, those closely related should be placed together. (Abu Dawud) • Prisoners should live in comfort. Muslims should 58 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 care more for the comfort of their prisoners than for their own. (Tirmidhi) • Emissaries and delegates from other countries should be held in great respect. Any mistakes or discourtesies they commit should be ignored. (Abu Dawud, Kitan Al-Jihad) • If a Muslim commits the sin of ill-treating a prisoner of w a r, atonement is to be made by releasing the prisoner without ransom. • When a Muslim takes charge of a prisoner of war, the latter is to be fed and clothed in the same way as the Muslim himself. (Bukhari) The Holy Pr o p h e t( s a ) was so insistent on these rules for a fighting army that he declared that whoever did not observe these rules, would fight not for God but for his own mean self (Abu Dawud). Abu Bakr, the First Khalifa of Islam, supplemented these commands of the Pr o p h e t( s a ) b y some of his own. One of these commands appended here also constitutes part of the Muslim t e a c h i n g : • Public buildings and fruit- bearing trees (and food crops) are not to be d a m a g e d . ( M u ’ a t t d ) From the sayings of the Pr o p h e t( s a ) and the commands of the First Khalifa of Islam it is evident that Islam has instituted steps which have the effect of preventing or stopping a war or reducing its evil. As we have said before, the principles which Islam teaches are not pious precepts only;. they have their practical illustration in the example of the Pr o p h e t( s a ) and the early Khalifas of Islam. As all the world knows, the Pr o p h e t( s a ) not only taught these principles; he practised them and insisted on their o b s e r v a n c e. 59 The Qur’an on War and Peace Review of Religions – February 2002 We hope you have enjoyed reading this edition of the magazine. The Review of Religions will continue to prov i d e discussion on a wide range of subjects and welcomes any comments or suggestions from its readers. To ensure that you regularly receive this monthly publication, please fill in your details below and we will put you on our mailing list. The cost of one year’s subscription is £15 Sterling or US $30 for overseas readers (Please do not send cash). Pa y m e n t s should be made payable to the London Mosque and sent to the address below: The Review of Religions The London Mosque 16 Gressenhall Road London SW18 5QL United Kingdom Please put me on the mailing list for the Review of Religions for 1 year. I enclose subscription payment of £15.00 or US $30.00. Name: ___________________________________________ Address: __________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ Subscription Review of Religions The Holy Ka’aba MECCA, ARABIA The First House of Worship, and The Spiritual Heart of Islam